Skip to main content

Anti-imperial Block of Nations

At the end of September, it became known that the concept of Tatarstan identity was excluded from the programme of the updated state national policy of Tatarstan. The concept of “Tatarstan citizenship” also disappeared. The goal of the state programme that was in force before this was “strengthening the all-Russian civil and Tatarstan identity.” Now the main goal of the republican government is “strengthening the all-Russian civic identity and unity of the multinational people of the Russian Federation.”

The updated state programme is designed for 2024-2026. The total budget is 145.2 million rubles. By 2026, a goal has been set: 80% of Tatarstan residents should feel a close connection with their Russian compatriots.

Minister of Culture of Tatarstan Irada Ayupova , who will be responsible for the implementation of the programme, explained to Business Online that these changes are only a technical issue. She said that the program of national self-determination of the Tatar people works separately. Ayupova emphasized that there was no pressure from Moscow.

The policies pursued in Russia in recent years clearly show that the powers of the national republics are being narrowed, national issues are being supplanted, and the influence of the Russian language is increasing. In 2017, the Tatar language ceased to be compulsory in schools in Tatarstan, and the agreement between Russia and the republic on the distribution of powers was not extended. At the beginning of this year, under pressure from Moscow, amendments were made to the Constitution of Tatarstan: the concepts of “president”, “sovereignty” and “citizenship of Tatarstan” were removed from it. At the same time, the commission for the protection of the Tatar language was combined with other languages ​​of the republic, and a separate commission was created for the Russian language. In Tatarstan, it has become impossible to obtain a Russian passport with a Tatarstan insert.

The correspondent of Radio Azatlyk (Tatar-Bashkir service RFE/RS) spoke with historian and ethnologist Damir Iskhakov in the new era of Tatarstan authorities.

— Why, in your opinion, was the concept of “Tatarstan identity” removed from the national policy program?

“This was definitely done under pressure from Moscow. This corresponds to the general line of policy pursued in Russia. Valery Tishkov ( scientific director of the Institute of Ethnology and Anthropology of the Russian Academy of Sciences – “Idel.Realii” ), who determined the ideological side of this policy, introduced the concept of the “Russian nation”. In fact, this means strengthening one nation in the state. Before that, they made changes to the Russian Constitution and prepared the basis. Now only Russians are considered the state-forming people. Other nations stand aside. Russian remained the main language. This is an imperial policy. As long as we follow this path, there is no point in federalism in Russia. This trend contradicts the federal state structure, which is still enshrined in the Russian Constitution.

In 2020, the Constitution of Russia enshrined the provision that Russian is the language of the state-forming people of Russia. This amendment, proposed by Vladimir Putin, according to experts and activists, legally and de facto established the dominance of both the Russian language and Russian identity, which can only strengthen the already ongoing Russification and forced assimilation of other indigenous nations of Russia. Activists have repeatedly criticized these changes.

— So from the steps taken by the authorities it follows that they intend to create one ethnic group in Russia.

“This is clearly evident from the current policy. Tatars are allowed to sing, dance and have fun. When it comes to language and education, harassment begins. Russian remains the main language of instruction in education. In fact, this is a political issue. One of the main symbols of a nation is its native language. If there is no opportunity to develop it, you will be forced to live on the basis of another language.

Right roll. Council of Europe expert spoke about the ethnic policy of Putin’s Russia

— Experts agree that Russia today is de facto a unitary state. How does the disappearance of federalism affect Tatarstan identity?

— Tatarstan identity is based on the self-determination of the Tatar nation. If you suppress or weaken the Tatar direction, this will mean that the Tatarstan identity will also weaken. The Tatars are the state-forming nation in Tatarstan. If it is abolished, then there will be no more meaning in Tatarstan. The name begins to not correspond to the body – and a rollback occurs in all directions. Sociologists have been studying this question for a long time. Tatarstan identity turns out to be a meaningless thing without Tatar identity.

The editor of Russia Today does not see any problems with federalism and infringement of national languages

— Why should there be a “Tatarstan identity”? Why are regional identities needed?

— Russia is home to not just one nation, but many nations. If Russia is a federation, then the people behind each republic are organized as a nation. This is customary all over the world. Although they tried hard to abolish the republic, it continues to be a form of state. Russia can only be viewed as a union of nations. If we follow today’s path, federalism will disappear. There will be only one type of empire.

Before this, there was the concept of citizenship of Tatarstan. It was removed from the Constitution. In fact, the passports were also cancelled. A citizen of Tatarstan had the right to be considered a Tatarstan citizen. Now the concept of “Tatarstan” is losing its meaning. That is, something similar to the Kazan province appears, but at the same time only the “Russian nation” automatically remains. If there were citizenship, the Russian republics could also have a “Tatarstan identity.” To do this, it is necessary to have democracy and the possibility of having the institution of citizenship.

— After gaining sovereignty in 1990, former Tatarstan President Mintimer Shaimiev and his political adviser Rafael Khakimov came up with the concept of the “Tatarstan nation” or “Tatarstan model.” Why didn’t it work?

— This concept has lost its force. Before this, according to Khakimov’s concept, the Tatarstan nation was considered a separate political entity. It was a mistake. To create such a structure, each nation must initially have its own place, and the Tatars must form its basis. This can only be realized if the Tatars and other nations have the right to citizenship. Now the Tatars, who form the basis of the Tatarstan nation, are disappearing. It has become a meaningless construct.

Janusz Bugajski: Tatarstan and Bashkortostan will be the first to strive for separation from imperial Russia

— Was the main mistake that in the concept of the “Tatarstan nation” they put socio-economic status in first place?

– This is impossible from a national point of view. Now you work hard, and then Moscow takes it for itself. What benefit does this have for the people? If there was democracy and federalism, the people could have their say, demand how much wealth should remain in Tatarstan, and share the income. In ordinary countries, the center and regions share income 50/50. No matter how hard you work now, everything can be taken away at any moment.

Expert: decentralization of financial decisions reduces the level of corruption

— How many people today consider themselves “Tatarstan”?

“It’s impossible to say for sure now. A fifth of the population considers themselves Tatarstan residents. In the 1990s, a third of the republic’s population had such an identity. This is based on sociological research. This issue is not currently being studied.

— How many people consider themselves “Russians” in Tatarstan?

“There are some like that too, but I can’t tell you the share.” We have two identities – “Russian” and “Tatarstan”. There are probably as many of those who consider themselves only “Russians” as there are “Tatarstan residents”, and maybe even fewer. At least that’s how it used to be. Most of those who consider themselves “Tatarstanians” also call themselves “Russians.”

The self-identification “Russians” dominates the perception of residents of the Russian Federation and has no significant competitors. This conclusion was reached by the authors of a comprehensive study conducted this year by the Platform Centre and the Centre for Socio-Political Research and Information Technologies (TSSPIIT) of the Russian State University for the Humanities. To the open question “If you were faced with the task of naming all the inhabitants of Russia in one word, how would you do it?”, 60% of respondents answered “Russians.”

At the same time, for the majority of respondents (72%), “nationality” and “Russian” are close concepts that mean almost the same thing, it follows from the research data.

— Earlier you said that Bashkortostan did not follow this path, but went towards ethnocracy. Whose model turned out to be more viable?

— In Bashkortostan they are moving forward more successfully. It turned out that for their own benefit, they work more. Due to our shortsightedness, we missed this opportunity. All the same, the basis of the republics is the main nation. It’s not for nothing that the republics are named after them. It is possible to give equality to other nations, but it depends on how everything is arranged. There are problems regarding the language of the state and other nations, which culture should be given priority. Bashkortostan played in its favour and therefore took a relatively more profitable path.

However, this is a short-term policy. It’s impossible to go on like this for long. If there is democracy and normal voting, the path chosen by the Bashkirs will immediately break down. Therefore, the prospects for Tatarstan look more favourable, but this can only be organized if there is democracy. In the meantime, we are losing.

— In Tatarstan, the Tatar language became voluntary for study in schools; the agreement between the federal centre and the republic was not extended. After February 24 last year, a commission was created to protect the Russian language, and the Tatar language was merged with other languages. Later, the words “citizenship” and “sovereignty” were deleted from the Constitution. Is all of the above part of the policy of building a “Russian nation”?

– This is how the politics of chauvinism flourishes. Russians are called the main nation. Other nations exist only if the Russian eye pays attention to them. The textbook “Fundamentals of Russian Statehood” recently developed for universities shows a desire to construct the history of the state through the prism of the current era. Russians are in first place there. Other nations are mentioned only in passing. This is the trend.

— How do you think the attempts to build one nation and leave one religion will end?

“Looking into the future, I am sure that this policy will not be successful. Let me give just one argument. According to the United Nations forecast, by 2050 the share of Muslims living in Russia will reach 37-38%. If you only promote Orthodox Christians and Russians, you are alienating most of the population. Such a state can never prosper. You can try to build this policy temporarily, but it will not be maintained in the future. Therefore, although the situation of the Tatars is difficult now, I think there is still hope for the future. Other nations will also demand democracy. We must not give in to pessimism.

Original publication: Radio Liberty

 

Note: for a quick information search please subscribe to our Telegram channel “Freedom for Nations!”  https://t.me/ABN_Freedom_for_Nations

Also, read the Facebook materials of the ABN page and the group

Our site: https://abn.org.uaen/

Idel.Реалии

More from the category

The truth cannot be blocked, and the voice of freedom cannot be silenced! October 27, 2026 Interviews On 26 October, Turarbek Kusainov, head of the NGO "Demos", published an interview with Nafis…
Budanov believes Russia will face a difficult choice – Warthog Defence September 25, 2026 Interviews The Kremlin will have to choose between continuing the war and preserving Russia's internal stability,…
Dorzho Dugarov spoke about Buryatia’s independence and the collapse of the empire September 3, 2026 Interviews Buryat activist, publicist, and human rights defender Dorzho Dugarov is a guest on the new…
Rafis Kashapov. Ukraine’s victory is a watershed: why we work with Harry Kasparov September 3, 2026 Interviews Harry Kasparov calls Ukraine's victory a condition for the collapse of the imperial project, and…
Why are the people of Sakha talking about secession from Russia? An interview with Raisa Zubareva August 26, 2026 Interviews In a new interview, Ruslan Gabbasov discusses the most pressing issues with Raisa Zubareva, leader…
Alik Gomelsky: Stepan Bandera without myths: OUN(B), UPA, Jews, Poles, KGB, CIA and archival documents August 26, 2026 History, Interviews Stepan Bandera remains one of the most controversial figures in 20th-century Ukrainian history. Who was…